InsightDeck / Seasonality / November / Best Six Months (Nov–Apr)
Best Six Months (Nov–Apr)
The saying
The six months from November to April are said to bring bigger gains than the six months from May to October. Because the split falls on October 31, it is also called the Halloween indicator.
About this saying
What it says
The mirror image of “Sell in May”: the year is split in two, and the winter half is said to be stronger.
Why people say it (explanations offered)
Thinner summer trading and money flowing in around the turn of the year are among the reasons given. None of them has been established.
What to keep in mindStocks rise in most periods anyway, so the comparison is with any six-month window. The following May–October is shown alongside.
Checking the data
Kenneth R. French Data Library (based on CRSP data). Whole US stock market (value-weighted), dividends included, US dollars. Window: November 1 to April 30. 100 observations, 1926–2025 (data through 2026-09-30). Values are total returns over the window, dividends included.
November–April beat the following May–October in 67 of 99 years. The following May–October rose 71 times out of 99, averaging +3.96%.
November–April return (labeled by the November year)
One bar per observation: up in navy, down in gray. The shaded area marks 2000 onwards
Source: Kenneth R. French Data Library (based on CRSP data). Whole US stock market (value-weighted), dividends included, US dollars
By period: share of observations up
Navy: the saying's window. Thin gray: the comparison. Vertical line: 50%
Comparison: all six-month windows (1198 windows). The windows overlap, so they are not independent
Before and after the cited study or almanac
Before and after Sven Bouman and Ben Jacobsen, The Halloween Indicator, 'Sell in May and Go Away': Another Puzzle, American Economic Review 92(5), 1618–1635 (2002). Thin gray: the comparison over the same years
Average: before 2002 +7.96% (comparison +6.03%); 2002 on +7.03% (comparison +5.77%). Many anomalies are said to weaken once they become known.
Year-by-year reviews
Reviews will be written one at a time from 2026 on. The November 2026–April 2027 review is planned for around June 2027. The data appears one to two months after a window ends.